by Alice McGinty
art by David Roberts
Chronicle Books
2022
2022
One of my coworkers has an interest in children's lit, and the other day she basically put Bathe the Cat into my hands and told me to read it. This is a cute rhyming story about a family trying to clean the house before Grandma comes, only to be repeatedly thwarted by the cat rearranging the chore list to avoid a bath, creating chaos as the family attempts to faithfully follow the now nonsensical instructions.
As my coworker observed, this is a book with a queer family, but it isn't about them being queer. I think the playful spirit of the book is a pretty good personality match for some gay men I've known, but really David Roberts could probably have drawn any family to go along with Alice McGinty's words, and the story still would've worked. We have two dads, both Black, with the narrator doling out instructions a bit fatter, possibly more femme, and more into African fashions, and the other dad a bit slimmer and more clean cut. There's an older White daughter who wears a dinosaur costume throughout the entire book, a younger Black son, and a Black baby, who gets to be the beneficiary of the chores, rather than having to chip in.
The structure of the book is built on playful repetitions. First one dad doles out 8 sensible rhyming chores to himself the others by making a list on the fridge using alphabet magnets.The cat doesn't want to be bathed, so we get a closeup of a paw rearranging letters. We go through the list again, but everything's wrong, suddenly we're mopping the dog and feeding the lawn. But the cat doesn't want to get vacuumed or mowed either, so... We get another variation of equal silliness, and then one very mixed-up one where we need to like, bathe the mop and Dad the Sarah. Finally the narrator realizes what's been happening, reasserts control, and since the cat likes this new chore list, everything gets done in time for Grandma's visit.
Mixed-up chores are a real kid's book classic, at least since the Amelia Bedelia stories and maybe longer, but Bathe the Cat puts a fun twist on an old theme. The rhymes are fun, as are the illustrations of everyone diligently attempting their nonsense tasks. I think kids might think a bit about grammar and how word-order can change the meaning of a sentence, especially after the last, silliest rearrangement. And if you know a kid who'd like to see a queer or blended family, in a setting where their identity is incidental to the story rather than central, this could be a good pick.
As my coworker observed, this is a book with a queer family, but it isn't about them being queer. I think the playful spirit of the book is a pretty good personality match for some gay men I've known, but really David Roberts could probably have drawn any family to go along with Alice McGinty's words, and the story still would've worked. We have two dads, both Black, with the narrator doling out instructions a bit fatter, possibly more femme, and more into African fashions, and the other dad a bit slimmer and more clean cut. There's an older White daughter who wears a dinosaur costume throughout the entire book, a younger Black son, and a Black baby, who gets to be the beneficiary of the chores, rather than having to chip in.
The structure of the book is built on playful repetitions. First one dad doles out 8 sensible rhyming chores to himself the others by making a list on the fridge using alphabet magnets.The cat doesn't want to be bathed, so we get a closeup of a paw rearranging letters. We go through the list again, but everything's wrong, suddenly we're mopping the dog and feeding the lawn. But the cat doesn't want to get vacuumed or mowed either, so... We get another variation of equal silliness, and then one very mixed-up one where we need to like, bathe the mop and Dad the Sarah. Finally the narrator realizes what's been happening, reasserts control, and since the cat likes this new chore list, everything gets done in time for Grandma's visit.
Mixed-up chores are a real kid's book classic, at least since the Amelia Bedelia stories and maybe longer, but Bathe the Cat puts a fun twist on an old theme. The rhymes are fun, as are the illustrations of everyone diligently attempting their nonsense tasks. I think kids might think a bit about grammar and how word-order can change the meaning of a sentence, especially after the last, silliest rearrangement. And if you know a kid who'd like to see a queer or blended family, in a setting where their identity is incidental to the story rather than central, this could be a good pick.





