Hannah Arendt
directed by Margarethe von Trotta
written by Pamela Katz and Margarethe von Trotta
The Match Factory
2012
Hannah Arendt is a biopic covering a specific period in Arendt's life - the time during which she wrote Eichmann in Jeruselem.
The film actually opens with the Mossad capturing Eichmann in Argentina. We see Arendt's social life, hosting salons of other intellectuals, including Mary McCarthy, author of The Group. Arendt asks The New Yorker to send her to Israel to cover Eichmann's trial - she meets family there, then attends the trial as a journalist. We see actual historical footage here. No actor portrays Eichmann or the witnesses - we are shown the real thing.
Afterward, Ardendt returns home where she takes too long writing her article, worrying over her husband's health, and, via flashbacks, regretting her student-teacher love affair with Martin Heidegger. He, famously, embraced Nazism while remaining a university professor, while she fled to France, and was later put into a concentration camp by the Vichy government.
When her New Yorker articles come out, people are put off by Arendt denying that Eichmann is monstrous or even extraordinary. In her view, what's frightening about him is his willingness to follow orders with maximum efficiency, without caring one way or the other what the result of his work will be. This makes him no less guilty, in Arendt's view, though many accuse her of defending him or sympathizing with him.
Her bigger problem is the section of her report about the ways that leaders of Jewish communities cooperated with Nazi demands (as did nearly all secular European leaders). The word didn't exist in the 1960s, but today we would say that Arendt got cancelled. She loses friends from her salon group, she is disowned by family in Israel, she nearly loses her job.
I don't know if it's comforting or depressing that so little has changed in the intervening 60 years. People still hate nuance, and will still condemn someone else for not delivering their own preferred take on a situation. All that's different now, probably, is that our technology enables us to do all this more easily and efficiently than ever. While reading and understanding remain as hard as ever.
Like the real Arendt, Hannah Arendt the movie sets itself a difficult task, several difficult tasks really. I don't think it fully succeeds. I think it tries to do too much, is too long, and maybe depends too much on the audience having pre-existing knowledge. (Also, although Arendt speaks English with her friend Mary, almost the entire movie is in German.)
The film wants to teach us Arendt's theory of 'the banality of evil', which she developed from watching the trial and wrote about in her New Yorker articles, and the book that collects them, Eichmann in Jeruselam. It also wants us to see what in the trial prompts her to think that, and to reject the alternate framing of Eichmann as supervillian that so many others prefer.
The film wants us to see her getting cancelled, to know what people were reacting to, but also to know why they're wrong. It wanted us to see what her social life and family life were previously like so we could see what she lost when many of those closest to her turned against her. And, it wanted to connect all this to her regrets about not denouncing Heidegger enough.
It's all too much, and honestly, the flashbacks would be the easiest to remove. I also think that someone who'd never heard of Arendt's theory before watching this film would come away with only a partial understanding of it. This was the aspect of the movie that might've benefited most from more time or exposition.
Also, as interesting as it might be to see midcentury intellectual salon culture, with its undercurrents of extramarital sexual desire and jealousy (and despite the verisimilitude these scenes provide), I think we could see the personal cost to Arendt without devoting quite as much screen time to her personal life.
Originally watched April 2023.





