Sunday, January 14, 2024

Wonder Woman: Dead Earth

 
 
Wonder Woman: Dead Earth
by Daniel Warren Johnson
2020
 
 
Wonder Woman: Dead Earth collects a 4-issue miniseries about Wonder Woman waking up from a medically-induced coma into a world that has been ravaged by nuclear war. She discovers a world without heroes, where humanity is on the brink of extinction, where giant monsters haunt the devastated landscape and periodically harry the last surviving remnants of our species.
 
Wonder Woman is discovered in the Bat Cave by some fortunate scavengers. She joins their tribe, and after being forced into a gladiatorial fight with a horribly mutated Cheetah, offers the tribes-people a new hope if they'll follow her and relocate to Themyscira, the hidden Amazon island, where she's certain that conditions will be better.
 
Wonder Woman espouses a philosophy of unconditional love, of using her godlike power to offer forgiveness and second chances to anyone who'll accept them, regardless of their past crimes. Cheetah, for example, resents being held in gladiatorial slavery, but Wonder Woman urges her to choose mutual survival over vengeance. In the aftermath of a war, her philosophy reminds me of Truth and Reconciliation.
 
Interspersed through all this are flashbacks to Wonder Woman's childhood that help to inform how she became the version of the character whom we see here.
 
On Themyscira, Wonder Woman learns the truth about the nuclear war that ended the world, about what happened to Batman and Superman, about how she ended up in her coma, about the origin of the monsters, about who is responsible - who needs forgiveness, or vengeance.
 
Johnson's art style is very different from the usual beautiful and statuesque way that Wonder Woman is usually drawn. Here, she looks like a cave woman. But the style suits the end-of-the-world setting. And with their scars, messy hair, muddy ripped clothes, and decidedly un-made-up faces, the characters in this book look, in their own way, maybe more realistic than most comic characters. Johnson's inks look more like marker than pen, and while I don't know his process, if you told me that he inked freehand without a pencil drawing underneath, I would believe you.

Thursday, January 11, 2024

Pricing the Priceless Child

 
 
Pricing the Priceless Child
The Changing Social Value of Children
by Viviana Zelizer
1985
 
 
Pricing the Priceless Child is something of a classic in sociology. It's an important look at the social construction of childhood, and Zelizer is also important for her studies, including this one, that show how cultural, non-economic factors influence how people think about money, markets, and other topics that professional economists try to lay exclusive claim to.
 
Zelizer looks at a series of inter-related changes that took place in the US between the 1870s and the 1930s, when American children went from 'useful' - contributing economically to their families by performing either significant housework or farmwork or wage labor outside the home - to 'useless' - contributing only love and affection. In Zelizer's words, by the 1930s, children had become sacred, economically worthless, and emotionally priceless.
 
The backstory to all this is declining childhood mortality in the 19th century, due in part to medical improvements like the discovery of antibiotics and invention of vaccines. When every parent expected about half their kids to die before reaching adulthood, often in infancy, I think there must have been a certain degree of emotional distancing that was almost universal. As children become more likely to live, it becomes safer to love them more, and with that love comes a new concept of childhood as a sacred time that deserves to be protected from adult realities.
 
One thing people (eventually) decided their children needed to be protected from was child labor. Middle class reformers decided this first, and child labor remained more common among the working class for longer, in part because those families truly needed the extra money.
 
What followed was a clash of class-based cultures, as reformers accused working-class parents of exploiting their kids and failing to love them, and poorer parents, who'd grown up learning trades in childhood themselves, argued that it was important for kids to learn industry and a work ethic and avoid the vice of idleness. But after decades of controversy, obviously, the movement against child labor won definitively. Children would work in order to learn how to, and receive an allowance to learn how to spend and save money.
 
Throughout this period, people came increasingly to believe that the economic value and the emotional value of children were in conflict, that any price attached to kids in the market somehow subtracted from their worth as members of their families. Zelizer argues that a lot of what was happening here was people figuring out how to think about money differently, so that it no longer seemed to profane the sacredness of childhood.
 
Also during this time, insurance companies began offering child insurance, not to replace a kid's lost wages if they died, but to pay for a funeral and headstone- instead of the anonymous mass graves that were poor kids' previous burying places.
 
As kids stopped being wage earners, the theory of damages in wrongful death lawsuits had to change too. Parents could no longer sue for lost future income; instead, they asked for compensation for what they'd already invested, and for the emotional pain of the loss.
 
Foster care and adoption changed too. Working teens used to routinely live with another family, earn room and board, and learn a trade by working for them. Parents who couldn't take care of younger kids had to pay someone - often a 'baby farmer' - to take over the childcare. Essentially these children were sold. Kids too young to work often died.
 
But as children became expected to provide only love and affection, adoptive parents stopped wanting teens and started wanting infants, and became willing to pay to take them, a total reversal of the earlier situation. But also, by this time, the public was no longer comfortable with the idea of parents 'buying' a child. In the same way that allowance is not supposed to be pay for housework, adoption fees became a way to pay for the work done to transfer custody of a child without actually paying for the child.

Saturday, January 6, 2024

Witch Hat Atelier 3


 
Witch Hat Atelier 3
by Kamome Shirahama
translated by Stephen Kohler
2019 
 
 
At the end of the previous volume of Witch Hat Atelier, new student Coco and best student Agott had just finished saving the merchant's son who was trapped under a boulder by the river, while the other witches were looking for other accidents up- and downstream. Somehow when Coco disintegrate the boulder, the whole shoreline there washed away. The Knights Moralis arrived to investigate, accused Coco of using forbidden magic, and prepared to erase her memory.
 
Fortunately, master witch Qifrey and the other students arrive back just in time. The knights are super inflexible, but Qifrey is able to get them to see reason - Coco is a kid, and a new apprentice who only knows a few spell symbols, and struggles to draw them well. As a final test, one of the knights gives her his own pen-wand and has her draw the disintegration sigil again, and sees that it's simply not powerful enough to cause the out-of-control effect we saw.
 
Qifrey notices that the bottle of ink he gave Coco has been replaced by another, and wonders if the disaster was caused by her spell being amplified by special ink. He keeps this revelation to himself though. (The audience sees that yes, this is special ink made with blood by the masked witch who seems to be using Coco to reintroduce forbidden magic back into the world.)
 
Qifrey and Coco make a special trip back to the wand shop. Qifrey and the wandmaker investigate the ink, including drawing a tiny light spell with it, which produces an enormous blinding flash. The wandmaker wants to call in the Knights Moralis, so Qifrey does what he's protected Coco from all this time and erases the old man's memory of that event. Meanwhile Coco learns from wandmaker's grandson Tartah that different ink ingredients can add or amplify various spell effects. She also learns Tartah's secret - he's colorblind, and so despite knowing so much about the ingredients and effects, he can only tell the inks apart by their labels once they're mixed.
 
We go back to the Atelier for more practice. Agott has master Qifrey's permission to take the second test, which will give her permission to cast spells in public. Still secretly though, so that the public doesn't learn that magic is drawn, and a skill that anyone could learn. That secret is one of the things the Knights Moralis use memory erasure to protect. They also forbid casting spells directly on a body - which forbids stuff like shapeshifting, but also any healing magic.
 
Qifrey tries to use the special ink bottle to track the masked witch, but she gets the better of him, nearly drowning him in his tower, then teleporting in to steal the bottle back.
 
Coco's been having nightmares about how she accidentally turned her mom to stone the first time she drew magic. So she's been getting up in the night to practice her drawing skills. She ends up fainting in front of Agott, and Qifrey takes her to the hospital, after stopping to get directions from Tartah. Then Qifrey and a bunch of doctors are called away to deal with a fire in town.
 
Tartah stays with Coco, and tries to get her medicine. The vials are unlabeled though. Tartah can magically dehydrate the potions to see the ingredients, but if it's powder, he can't see the color to tell them apart. In her fevered delirium, Coco reverses the disintegration sigil to make, I don't know, a reintegration spell. When Tartah holds the sigil up to a powder, it stays powder, but like, temporarily reassembles into its original shape. With the help of this spell, Tartah finds the right medicine, and later gets scolded by a nurse, who is nonetheless impressed by his apothecary knowledge.
 
Coco thinks she can draw a reverse sigil of the spell that turned her mom to stone to save her, although I'm like super certain that's not going to work, just based on the limitations of the reintegration spell. Also, elsewhere, the masked witch is joined by an ally who is either invisible, or somehow is literally just a magic hat and cloak, and the two plot to do something attention-getting at Agott's exam.

Tuesday, January 2, 2024

Time Salvager

 
 
Time Salvager
by Wesley Chu
2015 
 
 
I think I actually started this project with a time travel novel I was reading over New Year's. But while The Tourist was more of a satire and puzzle, set primarily among time traveling tourists in the present day, Time Salvager is a bit harder scifi. 
 
In the solar system of the 2500s, there is no central government, and a handful of mega-corporations hold almost all the power. The last golden age ended by 2100, and it's been downhill ever since, with a series of ruinous interplanetary wars decimating the population and the environment. The ability to build any of the wonders of the past is gone. Humanity only survives because the 'ChronMen' use time travel to secretly visit the past and steal resources from right before major disasters where they'd be destroyed anyway.
 
Ever since watching First Contact, I've been a fan of scenarios where someone from the far future visits the near future. William Gibson's The Peripheral does it too. Every version of La Jetee and 12 Monkeys have envisioned time travel being used on scavenging and salvaging missions. And the tv show Loki is the most recent example I can think of where time travelers jump very close to cataclysmic events because they know their presence will have no effect. Also the ChronMen all have forcefield devices that work kind of like Green Lantern rings, or I guess like Lensman lenses.
 
So I like the setup for Time Salvager, although I kind of think it might make a better roleplaying game than it does a novel.
 
James is one of the best ChronMen, but lately he's been suffering from more time travel sickness, he's haunted by his sister who disappeared when they were children, and he's wracked with guilt over all the people he's watched die instead of saving them. (He's very literally haunted, by overly lifelike hallucinations and dreams where they scold him for letting them die.) 
 
James is getting close to quitting or killing himself when the nonprofit, quasi-governmental organization he works for gets an offer from a megacorp to steal some parts from a golden age arctic science facility right before it exploded. Some of the details seem fishy, but the pay is so good James could practically retire, so he accepts. 
 
During his two days of pre-explosion scouting, James has a meet cute with a scientist named Elise, and goes on a date with her so he can copy her keycard access. Then the giant explosion happens and he steals the parts, but he can't leave immediately because there's a rip in time caused by somebody else having time traveled to this same location before him. He waits, and ends up protecting Elise with his force field while they watch everyone else dying of radiation poisoning around them. When he can finally jump home, James breaks the rules and brings Elise with him.
 
James and Elise are very quickly forced to become fugitives on the environmentally devastated 'present day' Earth of the 2500s. The sun gives you radiation burns, the air reeks of greasy smoke that sticks to everything, the oceans are covered with thick layers of brown scum. While camping in the ruins of Boston, they find and are adopted by a tribe of wasteland dwellers who are essentially non-people as far as the megacorps are concerned. 
 
James uses his time travel equipment to benefit the tribe, and Elise continues searching for the cure for the 'earth virus' that had just been discovered in her time and is partially responsible for the awful state of the planet in James's. And of course the megacorp funder and the time travel agency are hunting for them, since James is a traitor and Elise is a time anomaly, setting up a big climactic forcefield fight at the end. 
 
We also learn that the corp paid a previous time traveler to set the bomb that destroyed the research station. This probably didn't change history much because WWIII breaks out so soon afterward and would've killed all those people anyway, but it's an ugly use of a supposedly beneficial technology to advance one company's interests. The corp is also incredibly brutal and heavy-handed toward the various Earth tribes while they search for James and Elise.
 
My favorite parts of the book were the glimpses at all the future wars and disasters that James could jump into, including a time during the AI Wars when Mountain Hulks flattened cities like glaciers. Early on, we see a rogue time agent jump to the Ming Dynasty and start a martial arts legend that changes history, and James steals the famous missing Amber Room from a Nazi castle before it's bombed. I kind of hate things like that, that purport to explain some real world phenomenon with fictional time travel. Those also both felt like misses opportunities to go somewhere cooler in the imagined future.
 
James's hardboiled cynicism and Elise's initial naivety both seemed kind of cliched and overstated, but I think Chu came into his strength when the pair were joining the tribe. Chu seemed to have a realistic view of what survival in that environment would require, and by putting both characters to work on a greater good (even though they both ostensibly had altruistic careers before that) he was able to show a side of them that he could render more humanely. The various side characters, most of them from the time travel agency, remained more one-dimensional throughout the book.
 
This one sort of ends on a cliffhanger, since the corporation is sure to make another try at coming after James and Elise after their first attempt fails. And we need to see what happens with the 'cure the virus' plot, and the whole 'corporation using its money to corrupt a supposedly neutral government agency' plot. There is a sequel. But based on where this one ends, I kind of feel like I know the basic outlines of what will happen next. I also fear Chu might give in to the temptation to make the entire crapsack future be the fault of corporate-sponsored time travelers repeatedly sabotaging humanity; this wouldn't really make any sense, and if he goes that route, I'd rather not see it.

Monday, January 1, 2024

Everything I Read in 2023

January
How to Read Chinese Ceramics edited by Denise Leidy
Rasputin's Bastards by David Nickle
Sirens and Muses by Antoina Angress
The Girl from the Other Side 7 by Nagabe
The Scrapbook of Fankie Pratt by Caroline Preston
Twee by Marc Spitz
Revenge of the Librarians by Tom Gauld
Blankets by Craig Thompson
Dark Nights: Death Metal by DC Comics
Gentlemen Callers by Caroline Hoex
 
February
Not Good for Maidens by Tori Bovalino
Dark Nights Death Metal: The Darkest Knight by DC Comics
Dead Memory by Marc-Antoine Mathieu
Ace by Angela Chen
There is No Antimemetics Division by qntm
The Girl from the Other Side 8 by Nagabe
Dark Nights Death Metal: The War of the Multiverses by DC Comics
Nutcracker Nation by Jennifer Fisher
Dark Nights Death Metal: The Multiverse Who Laughs by DC Comics
 
March
The Girl from the Other Side 9 by Nagabe
The Hod King by Josiah Bancroft
Justice League: Death Metal by DC Comics
Moose's Book Bus by Inga Moore
The Inugami Curse by Seishi Yokomizo
Shirley Jackson's The Lottery by Miles Hyman
Flung Out of Space by Grace Ellis, art by Hannah Templer
Finite and Infinite Games by James Carse
Terrarium Craft by Amy Aiello and Kate Bryant, photos by Kate Baldwin
The Best American Comics 2013 edited by Jeff Smith
Little Witch Hazel by Phoebe Wahl
 
April
Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin
Cycle of Fire by Hal Clement
Geometric Regional Novel by Gert Jonkers
Demon Days by Peach Momoko
Welcome to St Hell by Lewis Hancox
The Subplot by Megan Walsh
The Memory of Babel by Christelle Dabos
Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow by Tom King, art by Bilquis Evely
The Girl from the Other Side 10 by Nagabe
What If, Pig? by Lizzie Hunter
 
May
We Have Never Been Modern by Bruno Latour
Foreign Bodies by Kimiko Hahn
Loveless by Alice Oseman
The Alliance of the Curious by Philippe Riche
Retronaut edited by Chris Wild
Black Sun Rising by CS Friedman
Haunter by Sam Alden
Toxic Flora by Kimiko Hahn
The Girl from the Other Side 11 by Nagabe
Spelunky by Derek Yu
Decelerate Blue by Adam Rapp, art by Mark Cavallaro
Important Artifacts and Personal Property by Leanne Shapton
 
June
Meander, Spiral, Explode by Jane Alison
The Many Deaths of Laila Starr by Ram V, art by Filipe Andrade
The Queen in the Cave by Julia Sarda
This is How We Fly by Anna Meriano
Fantastic Four: Full Circle by Alex Ross
Love in the Library by Maggie Tokuda-Hall, art by Yas Inamura
Chess Story by Stefan Zweig
RUR by Karel Capek
Giraffes on Horseback Salad by Josh Frank and Tim Heidecker, art by Manuela Pertega
Life Between Tides by Adam Nicolson
 
July
Ex Libris by Matt Madden
Impossible Views of the World by Lucy Ives
Press Enter to Continue by Ana Galvan
A is for Bee by Ellen Heck
Gigantic Worlds edited by Lincoln Michel and Nadxieu Nieto
The Best American Comics 2014 edited by Scott McCloud
The Fall of Babel by Josiah Bancroft
 
August
Ducks by Kate Beaton
The Castle of Crossed Destinies by Italo Calvino
Forest Hills Bootleg Society by Dave Baker and Nicole Goux
7th Time Loop 1 by Touko Amekawa, art by Hinoko Kino
For the Birds by Elizabeth Cherry
 
September
Easy Tiki by Chloe Frechette, photos by Lizzie Munro
Trapped on Zarkass by Yann, art by Didier Cassegrain
Whistle by E Lockhart, art by Manuel Preitano
Six Angry Girls by Adrienne Kisner
7th Time Loop 2 by Touko Amekawa, art by Hinoko Kino
 
October
Radial Symmetry by Katherine Larson
The Curator by Owen King
The Oracle Code by Marieke Nijkamp, art by Manuel Preitano
Witch Hat Atelier 1 by Kamome Shirahama
Deadly Quiet City by Murong Xuecun
The King in Yellow by INJ Culbard
Galaxy: The Prettiest Star by Jadzia Axelrod, art by Jess Taylor
Tokyo Jazz Joints by Philip Arneill and James Catchpole
Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir
 
November
The Plain Janes by Cecil Castellucci, art by Jim Rugg
Catwoman: Lonely City by Cliff Chiang
Islands of Abandonment by Cal Flyn
Nanotech edited by Jack Dann and Gardner Dozois
Minor Detail by Adania Shibli
Witch Hat Atelier 2 by Kamome Shirahama
 
December
Sea of Stars 1 by Jason Aaron and Dennis Hallum, art by Stephen Green
Berlin Girls 1923 edited by Thomas Negovan
Berlin Girls 1925 edited by Thomas Negovan 
The Storm of Echoes by Christelle Dabos
A Small Miracle by Peter Collington
Kingdom of Characters by Jing Tsu

Friday, December 29, 2023

Kingdom of Characters

 
 
Kingdom of Characters
The Language Revolution that Made China Modern
by Jing Tsu
2022
 
 
Kingdom of Characters tells the history of seven different innovations of the 20th century that Tsu narrates as a single century-long effort to 'modernize' the Chinese language, to allow China script to be reproduced mechanically, and later electronically.
 
Throughout, the challenge is that Chinese script consists of characters that represent whole words (or that pair or triple up to make compound words, like 'boardgame.') Because of this, there are thousands of characters in very regular use, and tens of thousands in an expanded vocabulary. And these characters are not phonetic - there's no relationship between how the character looks and how the word sounds when spoken. These features can make Chinese challenging to learn to read, and means that it's not easily retrofitted into technologies designed for alphabetic languages.
 
Tsu tells this story in seven chapters, each focusing on a key technology, and proceeding chronologically from 1900 to the 1990s. The events he describes parallels, and sometimes intersects with, China's political history. I knew a bit of this, but more familiarity would've helped me. She describes what's most necessary at each point, but doesn't say much more than that. At points I would've liked more of an overview or more context. Other times, it seemed strange to me that something like the Cultural Revolution or the Tienanmen Square Massacre gets mentioned only in passing, and solely to help timestamp another event. I'll readily acknowledge that my reactions say as much about me as they do about her.
 
Tsu doesn't glamorize - several language reformers are imprisoned or tortured, by leaders spanning from the Qing dowager Empress to Mao Zedong, and Tsu's sympathies are for the people, not the leaders. However, it also becomes increasingly clear that he is most concerned with Chinese as it's written in the mainland People's Republic of China. At several points he'll briefly note that something is different in Taiwan, Hong Kong, or Macau, but it seemed to me he found those developments to be of lesser importance. And in the couple places where Taiwan and the PRC make different linguistic choices, or come into direct competition, he picks the side of the PRC.
 
One thing Tsu does well throughout is to explain the features of written Chinese to the unfamiliar reader, and to make analogies to the Latin alphabet. I'll make an analogy of my own that's based partially on what I learned from Kingdom of Characters and partly on my looking up various concepts on Wikipedia as I went. Written Chinese is a bit like written Latin, the official script used to communicate publicly, while Mandarin and Cantonese are only the best-known versions of whole families of dialects that are at least as different from each other as Spanish is from Italian. Chinese isn't vernacular, but does enable communication between members of an enormous population who would otherwise find each other mutually unintelligible.
 
Tsu's story starts around 1900. China is still suffering from the aftermath of the two Opium Wars and the ongoing Western occupation of close to a hundred of its port cities. Only about 10% of the population is literate, mostly scholars, civil servants, and members of the royal Qing court. It's clear that Western countries have technology that China doesn't, and civic-minded people wonder how their country can 'catch-up' and participate in international society as an equal. Some blame the complexity and difficulty of learning Chinese script, and suggest abandoning it in favor of alphabetical writing.
 
The first innovation is a set of phonetic symbols drawn from written Chinese rather than the Latin alphabet. The innovator here develops the symbols as part of a new system for teaching Chinese writing, which did sound much easier to me than the Reverse Cut system used up until that point. The same guy is also partially responsible for Mandarin beating out Cantonese as the official pronunciation of the characters. He was a staunch advocate during the convention where it was debated, but arguably won due to his procedural tricks to influence how the delegates' votes were counted. A later phonetic syllabary known as Bopomofo (like 'the ABCs,' it's named for its first few sounds) lingers in the background of Tsu's narrative at least into the 50s. Bopomofo also uses calligraphy-derived symbols, but each is also explicitly paired with a Latin letter.
 
The second innovation is a Chinese language typewriter. Tsu discusses several prototypes, but I don't know if any made it into mass production. Most tried to use whole characters. One, developed by Chinese students studying in the US and Chinese American professors, builds the characters out of strokes the way a calligrapher would. That one caught the eye of the CIA, and rather than allow it to help members of the public communicate more easily, they reserved it for translating intercepted documents.
 
Third is a code for sending Chinese-language telegrams. In addition to resisting transliteration into the Latin alphabet, the Chinese inventors have to figure out how to order the four-digit numerical codes in a way that's sensible and allows quick look-ups, and they have to argue about pricing, since Morse Code numbers are all longer than letters, making Chinese telegrams much more expensive to send.
 
Fourth, and related to the above, was figuring out a way to put the words in a meaningful order to allow them to be looked up easily. The Kangxi Dictionary had provided an order since the 1700s, but it still required checking the dictionary first. The system that seemed most interesting and intuitive to me was Lin Yutang's idea to create an indexing order based on the strokes used to draw the characters as calligraphy, with the first stroke serving the same function as the first letter in an alphabetical word. The Four Corner system that became most widely used didn't seem particularly intuitive to me, but it was developed by a bigshot in the publishing industry, so he could sell the books explaining his method cheaper than his competitors, and ensure that his method was used in the index of every book he published.
 
In the background of these chapters, China is in political turmoil. In 1911, the Qing empire collapsed and was replaced by a nascent democratic government. This progressively collapsed as regional governors and opportunistic warlords ruled over their own little fiefdoms. Japan invaded and claimed territory. The Nationalists and Communists cooperated to defeat the smaller local governments to reunify China, then went to war with each other.
 
In the 1950s, the CCP launches twin initiatives to create an official Latin alphabet transliteration of the language, and to simply written Chinese by reducing the number of strokes needed to write each character. The transliteration is called Pinyin, and it replaces the missionary-developed system Westerners had been using until then. This is when 'Peking' becomes 'Beijing' - not because the city was renamed, but because the way Westerners wrote and pronounced it changed. I think Pinyin also fully supplants Bopomofo, or maybe Tsu just stops mentioning it. Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Macau all continue using the traditional, non-simplified version of the characters.
 
The sixth innovation is a computerized version of Chinese. Initially, instead of the four-number codes of the telegraph system, someone invents a four-letter code corresponding to each character, based on the first letter of the Pinyin name for the first four calligraphy strokes used to write it. He came up with the idea for this system while he was imprisoned for intellectualism during the Cultural Revolution.
 
The seventh innovation in a unified international coding scheme so that when you write a Chinese character on a computer, no matter which country you're in or who manufactured the computer, someone else can open the file and see the same character. Unicode accomplished this initially in 1992, and Taiwan moved first to ensure that the traditional versions of the characters were the official Unicode versions, with the simplified versions used in the PRC considered 'variants' (like how the yellow-skinned emojis are official and default, with all the human skin tones treated as variants.) Conferences to debate, add to, and amend Unicode continue to the present day, and Tsu has attended several to observe the process.

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

A Small Miracle

 
 
A Small Miracle
by Peter Collington 
Knopf
1997
 
 
I'm visiting relatives for the holidays, and my little niece has a current favorite book. At her request, someone has read it to her several times a day for the past few days, and I've taken a turn as well!
 
A Small Miracle is made like, and employs the painted art style of, other children's picture books, but Collington also put several frames on each page to tell a sequential story - so secretly, it's also a comic. This is a wordless book, so the entire story is told through the art.
 
On a cold winter morning, an old woman wakes up in her small wooden house. There's frost on the windows and holes in the floor. She checks her stove, but she's out of fuel. There's no food either, and no money to buy more. She wraps up in a coat and shawl, and takes her accordion, and goes outside. We see that her house is a wagon at the edge of a field by the woods. Based on the visual cues, I think the old woman is Roma.
 
She walks across several snow-covered fields and passes a church before she gets to town. It looks like she's somewhere in Europe, or maybe Britain, in something like the present day. She sees someone unloading a nativity display from the back of their car. Despite the snow, the town is bustling with people out shopping. She sets up between two shops and plays her accordion, but everyone passes her by. She falls asleep, and when she wakes up, it's nearing the end of the day. She has no money from playing, so she sells her accordion at the pawn shop.
 
As she leaves the shop, a thief on a motorbike drives by and snatches her purse. She follows the trail of his bike through the snow, and sees that he's gone into the church. He bursts out the front door on his bike holding a donation bucket, but the old woman grabs it and wrestles it from him, then rushes into the church and locks the door. She sees that he's knocked over the nativity display. She puts the bucket back and sets the nativity scene back up. She checks outside and the thief has left, so she starts her long walk home.
 
Along the way, she collapses in a field. The colors go from afternoon, to evening, to night. The woman's body is progressively covered by a blanket of snow. It's at this point that the titular small miracle occurs. (I think? You could also read this as the moment of the old woman's death, and what happens next as her symbolic welcome into the afterlife. But for the purposes of reading aloud to kid, it's definitely a miracle!)
 
The figures from the nativity scene - Mary and Joseph, baby Jesus, and the three Wise Men - come to life and rush from the church to the field. They lift the old woman and carry her to her wagon. They put her to bed. Mary and the baby Jesus sit by her bedside to comfort her. Joseph sets to work chopping wood for her stove. 
 
The three Wise Men take their gifts to the pawn shop, where the shopkeeper is thrilled by the gold and gives them a big handful of money. They buy back the accordion and then head to the grocery store. The other shoppers are like, very lightly surprised, but like the pawn shop owner, accept the little walking statues with remarkable aplomb.
 
Back at the wagon, there's fire in the stove, and Joseph is busy repairing the hole in the floor and any other flaws in the woodwork. The Wise Men cook the woman some dinner, and set out the accordion and remaining cash where she can find them. All the nativity figures leave to return to the church. The old woman wakes up, and is hugely surprised to see that she has warmth, and food, and money, and even her accordion back!
 
Contained in this story, I think, is a message from Collington about the worth and dignity of ethnic minorities, and about the proper use of the church's resources.